This is our first user review for the latest version of Adobe Photoshop. Since the vast majority of pro photographers and graphics pros use Photoshop, CS5 definitely deserves as much attention as we can give it. Besides being the first user review for CS5, this review by thecounsel offers a pretty good quickie overview. It’s a positive review and covers some of the new features in CS5, including Content Aware Fill and the improved HDR tools.
If you have Adobe Photoshop CS5 or any other Adobe software, we need your reviews! Reviews by community members are the foundation of PhotographyREVIEW.com. Writing a review before the end of July 2010 also qualifies you to win a Gold Level membership in F-Stop Gear’s Friends With Benefits Program (review contest page).
Featured Review: Adobe Photoshop CS5
by thecounsel (Intermediate)
| Price Paid: $0.00 from trial direct download Review Date: June 18, 2010 Used product for: Less than 1 month Overall Rating: |
5 of 5
Summary:
It’s hard to believe there has yet to be a review posted. I’ll put this out there right off the bat…I’m one of those photoshop users that probably doesn’t need all the bells and whistles that CS5 offers (or CS4 for that matter), but I like to have them just in case, and elements just doesn’t quite cut it for me. I don’t plan on doing 3D or video, so those area’s won’t be covered in here.
Compared to CS4, the layout is very similar. There are some minor aesthetic tweeks and the addition of CS Live (which I have yet to touch), but if you know your way around the previous version, you’ll do fine here.
Ithink the most touted addition to CS5 is the content aware fill function, which can be used both by selecting and filling, as you would to fill with a pattern or color, or with the healing brush. Provided you’re not expecting it to fill in anything very complicated, this is certainly a cool feature. I have yet to really figure out any pattern for where it gets its samples, but I have found it to usefull primarily when the surrounding area is fairly consistent. Any objects outside the selected area might end up getting tiled where you’re trying to clean up. The quick verdict is that it’s good for quick jobs, and it’s results are dependent on what surrounds it.
Another feature that is new is the refined edge tool. I’ve used this sparingly so far. From my trials, it does a nice job of smoothing out any jagged selections I may have made, and allows the finer details to come out that would be an otherwise major pita to select.
Another addition that I’m happy to see is the MAJOR improvement in photoshops HDR capabiliites. Most know that CS4′s hdr results were a joke, sending most to use Photomatix if necessary. Again, I’ve played with this for only a limited amount of time, but the results I’ve gotten are superior to what I’ve gotten with CS4. Being able to load, tone map, and continue editing all from one program is certainly a perk. I have yet to try to replicate any “grungy” images, but I was impressed with the mapping of a couple images for a “normalish” look. CS5 offers fewer controls then Photomatix. We’ll see if that’s good or bad.
I’ve only dabbled with the paint feature…only enough to know I still need to learn how to use it.
Strengths:
It now does everything you didn’t know you needed to do, and makes some things easier. It’s the industry standard I hear…it better deliver.
Weaknesses:
Expensive.
Similar Products Used:
Photoshop CS4
Paint.net
Customer Service:
N/A
Related Content:
Adobe Photoshop CS5 Announcement Article
All Adobe Software User Reviews
All Photography Software Reviews
Digital Photography Software Forum
More Photography Software News And Articles
Adobe Web Site
Leave a Reply