Nikon AF-S Nikkor 17-35mm f/2.8D IF-ED 35mm Zoom
Nikon AF-S Nikkor 17-35mm f/2.8D IF-ED 35mm Zoom
[May 26, 2000]
Phil Fairman
Intermediate
Model Reviewed:
AF-S 17-35mm f/2.8D IF-ED
Strength:
I tried to buy a 20-35 f2.8D just when they were being discontinued and was too late, I sold my 90s & 20mm2.8D to "finance" the purchase of this expensive but exquisite lens. As well as being an excellent scenery lens and fantastic for catching trains up close, it is a teriffic "party" lens with a diffused flash...really nice group shots IF you watch your angles. A bit heavy, but that provides steadiness, just about perfect!!Balances well on my F-100
Weakness:
Heavy, filters VERY expensive if you buy an ultra thin design. Very expensive to purchase, BUT, most excellent fast lenses are....They could leave out that expensive case it comes packed in, most uf us put the lens in our bags and the case in a closet...never to be used again, would save a few bucks...for the price of the case, they could include a polorizer.I miss the black "crinkle" finish like Nikon's other pro lenses. Loved my 20mmf2.8D, but image quality is equal with this exquisite zoom, allows framing and cropping that a fixed lens can't with NO compromise that I can see. Expensive, but worth it. Customer Service Never needed, but their tech support on the phone when I have had questions has been excellent.... Similar Products Used: Sold my 20mmf2.8D, also use 35-70mmf2.8d, 80-200mmf2.8D, 60mmf2.8DMicro,& 300mmf4ED..am considering a 28-105mm as a |
[Apr 02, 2000]
JEFF DYE
Professional
Model Reviewed:
AF-S 17-35mm f/2.8D IF-ED
Strength:
I had a Tokina 20-35 but wanted the Nikon for the extra range of focal lengths. A big selling point was the 9" close focusing. I used the lens in Kelso Dunes and was able to photograph texture, line, and tracks very closely. Leaving the lens at 17mm provides a very different perspective when close focusing. I also photographed Indian Rock Art and made photographs entirely different than on previous trips. I teach Landscape Photography and the majority of my adult students might benefit more from a fixed wide angle (20mm-24mm) instead of this very expensive zoom.
Weakness:
I had to sell alot of equipment to afford the stiff price tag. It's a beautiful lens but is large and heavy. I wish AF wide angle zooms were as easy to use as my fixed 24mm when setting hyperfocal. I'm keeping my 24mm when I want to travel light. Also, the user of this lens will probably need an oversize 77mm polarizer to avoid vignetting at 17mm and 77mm polarizers are also expensive. This is a great lens that I believe will become very popular in spite of it's price tag. Although it was designed primarily for the D1 it's great on the F5 and other bodies where full advantage can be taken of it's focal lengths. Customer Service Not needed so far. Similar Products Used: Tokina 20-35 Nikon 17-35 f2.8 AF Nikon 80-200 f2.8 AF NIkon 35-70 f2.8 AF Nikon 300 f4 AF Nikon 600 f5.6 ED AIS Nikon 85 f1.4 AF Nikon 105 f2.5 AI Nikon 24 f2.8 AIS |
[Mar 06, 2000]
Dana Hess
Expert
Model Reviewed:
AF-S 17-35mm f/2.8D IF-ED
Strength:
I bought this lens back in December, and after almost three months of use I wonder how I ever got along without it! This truly is a spectacular lens with swift (and silent) autofocus. I know it was designed with the new D1 in mind, but it really gives you that great 17mm "sweep" when used on a 35mm camera.
Weakness:
A little bigger and heavier than I thought it would be but it balances nicely on the F100. And, yes it is expensive. If you don't need the extra 3mms on the wide end, find a used 20-35 for around $1K. And, like most extreme wide-angle zooms, it's very susceptible to flare. If you're a (very) serious Nikon-toting amateur you'll want this lens sooner or later. If you're a pro, you'll need it sooner or later. The only tip I would pass along is this: If you have a compact 24mm f/2.8, don't sell it! Take it along for those times when you have to shoot into the sun. Customer Service Haven't needed it Similar Products Used: 80-200mm 2.8 AF-S |
[Mar 01, 2000]
YW LEE
Casual
Model Reviewed:
AF-S 17-35mm f/2.8D IF-ED
Strength:
One of the best 35mm ultra wide angle to normal wide angle zoom lens around. The silent wave motor is super quick and quiet. I have just bought this lens and love it for every aspect. The optics and picture quality are all first class. The AF-S from Nikon has indeed shown up as it is made for.
Weakness:
Nothing really but I know there are lots of people who say it is too expensive but good stuff will never come cheap. What you pay is what you get. Street price is around USD1600.00 and this baby is hot around town and you might not find it too easily. I used this lens with my Nikon F5 and this is a killer combo. Never wish anything better than this. Other lenses used are AF 80-200mm f/2.8D ED and AF 60mm f/2.8D MICRO. I am looking to trade for the AF-S for 80-200mm in my next upgrade. I shoot everything and I can heartedly recommend this body together with all the above very fine lenses. These are among the best stuff your money can buy. Customer Service Never tried yet. Similar Products Used: Other Leica lenses and I can tell you that this Nikon's line is the same as the best in this world. There is no som |
[Sep 18, 2000]
Steve Steele
Expert
Strength:
Very sharp edge to edge
Weakness:
None. In the 17-35 mm range, there is no other lens for me. I find that its sharp and without chromatic abberation from edge to edge. Its also very flare and ghost tolerant as well as quiet and sturdy. Why this lens is rated overall at 4.92 is beyond me. Similar Products Used: Primes in the same range |
[Sep 16, 2000]
Patrick Kong
Expert
Strength:
excellent build quality, superb optics, constant f/2.8
Weakness:
not that I can think of I used to own the AF 20-35/2.8 which I was most happy with. But after the hard time I gave it during the last few years including the photo trips to Turkey, Israel, Jordan and Egypt, I thought it was time to either service it or to replace it. I went for the latter option and tried this AF-S 17-35 f/2.8 lens. I recently took it to Malaysia and my jaw dropped to the floor when I got my slides back. I was amazed by its minimal distortion (important for my architectural shots), good control of flare and excellent colour rendition. There were no obvious signs of vignetting either. The smoother paint finish is smart but looks more prone to scratch than its predecessor's crackle finish. However I can confirm that it is just as durable after months of heavy use. It is true that this lens is heavier and larger than the 20-35, but when it is attached to my F3, F4 or F100, it balances very well and the extra bulk and weight are just not noticeable. This is a truely first class product from Nikon which they should be justly proud of. I will not hestitate to recommend this lens to anyone needing this type of glass. Customer Service not required so far Similar Products Used: AF Nikkor 20-35/2.8 |
[Oct 03, 2000]
Peter Jung
Expert
Strength:
Nicely hammered black satin finish similar to the finish on the Nikon F5 body.
Weakness:
In Canada, this lens is expensive relative to the U.S.A. prices. Even though the AF-S 17-35mm lens is in a different class than the AF-S 28-70mm lens, I felt that sharing the results will assist consumers in deciding which lens or lenses to buy. Customer Service Have not used yet for the subject lens. Similar Products Used: My idea of similar products tried would involve any prime or zoom lens with one or more similar focal lengths and f/stops. |
[Sep 28, 2000]
Richard Rosen
Intermediate
Strength:
Well built, super fast focusing, sharp image, good contrast.
Weakness:
viginets at 17mm with pol-cir filter, Must watch out for flare. When I compare the Nikkor 17-35 AFS to the Tokina, I am amazed at how much sharper the Nikkor is. The Tokina is no slouch. If you can afford it, get the Nikkor Customer Service None Similar Products Used: Nikkor 24-120-good travel lens |
[Oct 17, 2000]
Bernard Seng
Intermediate
Strength:
Extremely sharp & contrasty. Focusing range of 0.9ft, AF-S blistering fast & silent, very well-built, internal focus technology. Easy to install & remove lens cap with lens hood on -(Supposedly inherent quality). Good resale value.
Weakness:
Very expensive, you can get 5 primes (18mm, 20mm, 24mm, 28mm, 35mm) & have extra $ left for the price of this lens alone, but who wants to change 5 lenses in the field? My HB-23 hood seems abit tight to click into place, probably need abit of usage to smoothen it out. The casing - it ended in my store room right after I placed the lens in my camera bag. In order to ensure optical performance Nikon incorporated 2 ED & 3 aspherical elements which is why this lens cost a bomb. AF-S on a wide zoom seemed impractical, but once you get a taste of it, you reasoning will go out of the window, moreover coupled with my F100 - WOW!! (I tried it on the F80 & F70 as well). The lens is quite heavy, 745g but compact & is well-balanced on my F100. Because of the IF technology, the entire lens can be held without worrying about hindering the AF operation, providing extra holding area. The lens also does not change length while focusing. It also does not rotate making it easier to use POL-Cir filters provided it is of the thin design otherwise vignetting would occur at the wide angles. Customer Service None needed. Similar Products Used: Sigma 28-300mm f3.5-6.3; Sigma 28-70mm f2.8 EX; Sigma 50mm f2.8 macro EX; Nikon 50mm f1.4D |
[Oct 21, 2000]
Todd Krefeld
Expert
Strength:
Extrememly sharp, passes, and surpasses some Nikon primes of it's range. Very fast focus. Bright aperature. Solid build. Comes with case/hood. Excellent manual focus feel. Reaches to 17mm.
Weakness:
None This lens is as sharp as all the primes it comers, with no color fringing, and very little, to no flare even shooting directly into light. Customer Service Great Similar Products Used: Nikon: |