Canon EF-S 17-85mm f/4-5.6 IS USM 35mm Zoom
Canon EF-S 17-85mm f/4-5.6 IS USM 35mm Zoom
USER REVIEWS
[Dec 23, 2010]
Sandra Jolcanain
Expert
Strength:
Wrap up features of Canon EF-S 17-85mm:
Weakness:
The Cons:
Cannon’s EF-S 17-85mm is the main advancement from Canon’s EF-S 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 II kit lens. Its versatile “walkaround” lens makes it ideal when traveling light. Features included are extended focal length range, image stabilization, high quality manual focus option for fast and silent autofocus, and essentially improved build quality. So, if you have any thoughts of buying or upgrading your kit lens, Cannon EF-S 17-85mm is best fit for you and for your photographic activity.
|
[Dec 23, 2010]
loristm
Expert
Strength:
• Powerful ring-type ultra-sonic monitor (USM) produces fast and silent autofocusing (1.15ft close)
Weakness:
• Intrusion of magenta chromatic deviation and marked barrel distortion brings poor performance at wide-angle
Canon EF-S 17-85mm, a major improvement from Canon’s EF-S 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 II kit lens offers attractive features appropriate for individuals who are into photography while traveling light. Its extended focal length range, image stabilization (IS), good manual focus option for fast and silent autofocus, and essentially improved build quality makes it an ideal all-in-one “walk around” lens for Canon’s APS-C SLRs.
|
[Aug 03, 2010]
PJF
Intermediate
Strength:
-Affordable
Weakness:
-Lots of Chromatic Aberration
I bought this lens to replace the 18-55mm kit lens that came with my Canon EOS 450D as i felt that first optic just wasn't sharp enough. Upon handling the lens for the first time it felt significantly heavier than the 18-55mm which is evidence for its superior optical quality and build. The lens barrel has a matte black finish and does not significantly deform when pressure is applied, whilst the all-metal lens mount adds to the more professional handling experience. Meanwhile the focussing ring can be rotated at any time (full time manual focussing as it's known) due to the more advanced optical design than the kit lens, which is a useful feature in certain situations when the photographer wishes to tweak the focus after the AF system has done it's job. Both zoom and focus rings are of a manageable width and turn smoothly. Neither feels too tight or too loose and there is no 'creep' when the lens is stored vertically or aimed down or up. Overall the 17-85mm handles well, being comfortable to hold and having reassuring weight, whilst being highly portable. So it feels nice, but what about optical quality? Well when images are printed at A4 and larger or when they are viewed at 100% on the computer screen there is a clear advantage in sharpness over the 18-55 kit lens. When paired with a 12 megapixel camera like the 450D this glass can resolve a very decent amount of detail and contrast and colour is very good. Photos do tend to get a little soft towards the edges of the frame, especially at maximum aperture but this is to be expected. The lens' circular iris produces some very attractive Bokeh aswell which is a bonus for portrait and macro photographers. One place where it does fall down slightly is in terms of chromatic aberration. There is very obvious coloured fringing along high contrast edges which can distracting when looking at your pictures. However, if you're shooting RAW and you have Canon's Digital Photo Professional software this can be effectively removed post capture. There is some noticeable barrel distortion at the 17mm end of the focal length range but in most situations this isn't a huge issue and most certainly shouldn't be a deal breaker. Performance wise the auto focus is lightning-quick and very quiet thanks to Canon's USM and the IS system is very welcome in lower-light conditions.
Customer Service Park Cameras offered me a very good deal on this lens. It arrived rapidly only a few days after i ordered it, was well packaged and came with a free canon lens guide for me to drool over (pity they couldn't have sent me a free EF 200 f2 IS USM aswell!) Overall the service was good and i would recommend people who are looking to buy the 17-85mm or similar lens to keep an eye on Park Cameras' sales. Similar Products Used: -Canon EF-S 18-55mm IS
|
[Jan 24, 2008]
PapaCarlo
Intermediate
Strength:
Good focus range, build quality, light, focuses fast and silently.
Weakness:
VERY soft ! Got this in a kit with Canon 40D.
Similar Products Used: Canon EF 28-135
|
[Aug 13, 2007]
Groupcaptainbonzo
Expert
Strength:
Above average in all departments.
Weakness:
not yet found any This is an all round very able lens . It is a "Walk Round" lens. Therefore there are compromises in its design / construction.
|
[Jul 12, 2007]
cjnielsen
Intermediate
Strength:
Well built
Weakness:
Expensive for a non- L lens - NZ$1100
An excellent mid-range zoom. Photos are slightly soft but sharpen up nicely in Photoshop although at least it's consistent through all apertures and focal lengths. IS is impressive, and the lens is built tough by consumer lens standards. I dropped my 30D with this attached, and the lens hit the deck hood-first which bent the lens completely out of shape, but given a good yank it snapped back into shape and shows no damage or image quality problems at all.
Customer Service Not needed it yet! Similar Products Used: Canon 18-55
|
[Jan 29, 2007]
amelo14
Intermediate
Strength:
Unique Versatile Focal Range, Image Stabilization, USM, Low Weight, Low light possibilities
Weakness:
No hood, requires corrective post-processing, only EF-S. I got this lens as part of a deal which included it and the Rebel XT. If you can buy it as part of this kind of package, then it is a really GREAT deal. This lens is extremely convenient, specially for travel and those situations (quite common) in which you just can’t take too many lenses with you. Its versatility means it will be the only lens many will need. Some criticize its image quality and its distortions. The distortions can be fixed in very affordable programs such as PTLENS, and the image quality, specially above 35mm is extremely good. It is a great lens to have as a low-light alternative for situations such as those in museums where no tripod/flash is allowed. Besides, if you check out resolution figures which compare the famous “85 1.8” at 1.8 and this lens at 85 f/5.6 (+ 3 stops with IS which would be more or less equivalent to 1.8), you will see that the figures are almost identical (see, www.photozone.de). This lens also allows for nice bokeh.
Customer Service Excellent Similar Products Used: Tamron 17-50 2.8 |
[Sep 06, 2006]
Stewart Mcfadyen
Expert
Strength:
Image stabilisation.
Weakness:
Soft, soft, soft. Not good. Have had two brand new off the shelf samples of this lens from 2 very different suppliers niether sample was what I would classify as suitable for commercial use. Unsharp is the key word here. Even when stopped right down F11 and beyond the results are soft images. Sent one back the other is going on sale. |
[Jul 22, 2006]
andrewsfoto
Expert
Strength:
Five times zoom range equivalent to 28 - 135 mm on a full frame camera, fast accurate auto focussing ( more accurate when zoomed out to the long end ) Internal stabilisation that really works, reasonably priced, compact, no mechanical or functional problems thus far, after several thousand exposures. Excellent image definition at all focal lengths, except in the extreme corners, which is no big deal.
Weakness:
The most troublesome problem with this lens is strong chromatic aberration which presents as colour fringing in high contrast parts of photos especially at the wide end of the focal length range, and towards the edge of the frame. This can be reduced but not always eliminated in Photoshop. There is strong barrel distortion at the wide end, easily corrected in Photoshop, and darkening in the corners at the wide end, also easily corrected in Photoshop if desired. Some image softness right in the corners at all focal lengths wide open. I have used this lens on an EOD 20D for over a year. The 17 - 85 mm is an excellent all purpose lens, ideal for travelling when you want only one lens on the camera. Unlike some other posts on this site I have had no problems with image sharpness at any focal length or aperture. I have in fact been able to enlarge photos made with this lens up to A2 size, using bicubic in Photoshop while retaining excellent detail and definition. It was the excellent results I obtained with this lens which allowed me to realise I do not need a full frame digicam to achieve high quality photos. Customer Service Not required for this lens but usually excellent from Canon Australia Similar Products Used: EF 28 - 135 mm Zoom for film cameras.
|
[Jul 09, 2006]
jopattyn
Intermediate
Strength:
Zoom range, IS
Weakness:
Unsharp, purple fringing (CA), barrel distortion, poor colors and contrast, expensive. Although very promessing specs the lens has major flaws: barrel distortion, purple fringing in the corners in high contrast pictures. Dark in the corners and overall poor contrast and very bad colors. I tested the lens just one day and returned it to the shop. The lens even doesn't tand a comparisson to the standard kit EFS 17-55 lens. Read carefuly all critics on this lens and don't believe the "just perfect" comments. Very disappointing from Canon. Save your money for something else. |