Nikon Coolscan IV ED Film Scanners
Nikon Coolscan IV ED Film Scanners
[Apr 12, 2001]
Nawaf Alali
Intermediate
Strength:
- excellent quality
Weakness:
- complicated software (read summary) people have complained about some problems with the software and PC. i never had them. the scanner work absolutely fine. Customer Service not yet Similar Products Used: HP PhotoSmart S20 |
[Apr 12, 2001]
Waldemar Haak
Intermediate
Strength:
Sharp scans, good colors, good shadow detail, fast, quiet.
Weakness:
Software is "beta" Used it for a week. None of the reported crashes (use a Mac!). Excellent hardware and software - basically . The Photoshop plug-in didn´t work though, said, the "basic application doesn´t have enough RAM" - i have 450 MB allocated to PS 5.5., how much does the scanner need - 2 GB? Just a bug, that will be fixed soon, i guess. Otherwise the best 35 mm scanner i ´ve ever used, but i´m going for the 4000 ED, as soon as you don´t have to wait for a month for delivery in Germany. I hope, DMax is really 4.2, as promised by Nikon. Customer Service No need Similar Products Used: Nikon LS 20 |
[Apr 29, 2001]
David Shapiro
Intermediate
Strength:
scan sharpness--relatively easy to use--software is good once you get the hang of it.
Weakness:
Digital ICE only works with color images (no they don't tell you that anyplace in the manual). If you have dust or scratches, get ready to spend some time with photoshop! Scanner and software are finally working well and if you have only color you will like the job ICE does on your images. If you have black and white, better look for another solution since ICE isn't going to be much help. Customer Service This is an updated review. The replacement unit had the same problems as the first unit--crashes, autofocus errors, etc. After digging around on the web I found that there might be a usb problem with my motherboard and searched for updated drivers. After a few calls to the computer manufacturer's tech support and a few downloads and upgrades, and after asking tech support to move me to a level two tech, they were able to give me a few tweaks to get the scanner working. It now works great and has not crashed at all. I should note that I added 256mb of RAM to the computer since the last review. Similar Products Used: None |
[Apr 26, 2001]
Bob Gilbert
Professional
Strength:
One of the most detailed, accurate scanners I have ever seen. Fast scan times compared to others. Digital ICE, ROC, and GEM are great. I use this to restore old damaged slides - no scanner I have tried comes close. Multiple attempts - see weaknesses.
Weakness:
Now for the big one... If you've got one HECK of a computer it's great. Buy lots of RAM, and pray you don't have to scan 300 negatives in an evening. You won't get very far. They need to test this scanner out with a LOT more computers, and make the software more easy to use. ICE, ROC, and GEM work great with old trashed Kodachrome slides! I just wish the engineers would LISTEN to photographers a bit more, and get their academic heads out of the clouds. Every digital component made these days (cameras, scanners, printers) seems to fall short of 100+ years of film photography. Who do you engineers think you are? stop reinventing the wheel, and calling it digital! Customer Service Ok, but they can't fix my problem. Runs GREAT on a 900mhz Pentium III, but I am not going to replace my old 500 K6-2 just yet. Similar Products Used: Kodak 3600 |
[May 04, 2001]
Ben Plehal
Intermediate
Strength:
Outstanding resolution and color reproduction. ICE option is absolutely mind-blowing!
Weakness:
Software is a little un-intuitive. I have had a couple of crashes -- software patches should be available soon, I imagine. For the price, you can't beat the results. Some have complained about the speeds, but if you have a computer with some horsepower, it's not much of an issue -- Nikon's numbers are based on scan times only, and don't count data transfer or slow software manipulation of the image due to a slow machine or low system resources. I have consistently seen scan times of under a minute with ICE turned on. Customer Service Haven't needed it yet... Similar Products Used: None |
[May 03, 2001]
Suchismit Chakravorty
Expert
Strength:
*COLOR FIDELITY*
Weakness:
Takes forever to scan with GEM At first I was amazed by its small size, heck it is even smaller than my toaster ! Customer Service Didnt need any yet. Similar Products Used: Visioneer 7600 flat bad -- P.O.S. |
[May 14, 2001]
Igor Kiselev
Intermediate
Strength:
Perfect quality, I would say even better than LS2000. Truly deep tonal range, outsdanding color output. It keels its neighbours.
Weakness:
Does not run on My Win98 PC as a standalone Nikon software. I use it as a TWAIN source. I like it. It worth waiting so long to be on the stand. I presume 4000 brother kills all within its price. Similar Products Used: Coolscan III & LS2000, CanoScan FS2710. |
[May 23, 2001]
Bob Abbott
Intermediate
Strength:
Solid build, Nikon Name and reliability, Ice, Rock and Gem. 2900 dpi
Weakness:
NONE This scanner blows away all the others I have owned. It has never crashed or failed to give me a reliable scan. The colors come out great. I am using this on a Pent II 266 with 384 megs of ram. I waited along time for delivery but it was worth the wait. Customer Service Great Similar Products Used: HP Photosmart S20, Minolta Scan Dual, Nikon LS2000, Acer Scanwit 2740 |
[May 22, 2001]
Jeremiah Sanders
Professional
Strength:
Color accuracy
Weakness:
ICE makes images slightly blurred This is a beautiful scanner. My scans have turned out wonderfully. Side by side viewing with my slides vs. screen in PhotoShop v5 is magnificently accurate. Using this scanner with film taken on a Pentax ZX-5n and ZX-7, it has performed marvelously. I have no regrets about this purchase! BUY ONE! NOTE: Nikon Scan software does not function properly within the classic environment of Mac OS X. However, fuctioning within OS 9.1 is flawless. Installation even worked through Mac OS X! I experienced none of the difficulties in installation or setup previous users described. Customer Service Not needed Similar Products Used: UMAX PowerLook III |
[May 22, 2001]
Susan Larry
Intermediate
Strength:
Absolutely wonderful! I love the ICE, GEM and ROC. I've had no experiences with computer crashes or software problems. I use Photoshop 6. Great color rendering. But I haven't used any B&W film yet. I think the previews are quick and scanning time acceptable.
Weakness:
None that I can think of. If you can afford it, buy it! Customer Service No need. Similar Products Used: Kodak 3600.. piece of junk. Epson 1200U... great flatbed and medium format scanning. |