Tamron AF28-105mm f/2.8 LD ASP (IF) 35mm Zoom

Tamron AF28-105mm f/2.8 LD ASP (IF) 35mm Zoom 

USER REVIEWS

Showing 1-10 of 39  
[Nov 24, 2007]
oldsouthphoto
Expert

Strength:

Fast aperature, zoom range, and sharpness.

Weakness:

I wish it were metal. Some complain of weight - I believe bigger is better.

Fantastic lens. Sharp, I have had 3. The first was stolen with my Fuji S1. The second sits on my Canon 5d and the last on sits on my Nikon F5. This lens with its fast aperature and zoom range is a must for every photographer. When I shoot weddings - no one questions if I am using something they might have.

have read others examples have had some softness. The only thing I have noticed is some slight chromatic abberation. This lens is sharp. Buy the cleanest one you can find!

Tamron glass has always rivaled manufacturers lenses and this one is no exception.

Customer Service

Never needed!!

Similar Products Used:

Nikon 70-200mm f2.8 EDIF, Sigma 70-200mm f2.8 APO HSM Macro, Nikon 24-120mm, Nikon 35-70mm f2.8, Tamron 28-200mm XR

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[Jul 05, 2007]
Walter Fink
Professional

Strength:

The lens is a fast and sharp lens. Does shoot very close for, say the ring shot at a wedding. Perfect focal length for a wedding or the like. I like the nice lens hood included.

Weakness:

the lens is heavy, due to speed of the lens. Zooming is tight. Manual focus is smooth.

I purchased this lens, needing a fast lens for film. So far, the images are very sharp and crystal clear. I am still shooting this lens and will have alot more information later. I have used this for weddings and other photos where low light is present and I may need a fast lens. I would recommend this lens to anyone who wants a fast lens for film or digital.

Customer Service

I have not had a chance to use customer service. The lens keeps working.

Similar Products Used:

I have used other zooms of same focal lengths, but not speed. This lens, other than the weight and tighter zooming is a very nice lens for the low light shooter.

OVERALL
RATING
4
VALUE
RATING
4
[Nov 01, 2003]
Lawrence Sherman
Casual

Strength:

Good image quality throughout the aperture range, Good size, not cumbersome, but with the bulk and weight I like

Weakness:

The only weakness I found was the rather slow AF, especially in low light conditions. With the digital rebel in Full Auto mode,I pushed the shutter release and Nothing happened. I had to push it half-way down to allow it to focus before it would let me take the picture.

I just purchased the Canon Digital Rebel D300. This was my first foray into digital photography and I love it. I found the lens to be a delite. Heavy enought to make you feel it made well, and with the range I feel will make it a stay on all the time lens.

Customer Service

Not yet, too new

Similar Products Used:

Nikon lenses, all types, primarily zoom

OVERALL
RATING
4
VALUE
RATING
5
[Nov 01, 2003]
mrfisch
Expert

Strength:

Excellent image quality Very practical, and usable zoom range Solid consruction Fast, fixed aperture Adjustable "drag" setting for zooming

Weakness:

Don't buy if weight is an issue

Interesting how far apart the opinions are for this lens. I'm wondering if Tamron improved it in recent years as recent reviews seem much more positive. I have had this lens for about a week and use it on a Canon 10. It is the only NON- CANON "L" lens that I own, so I am veery critical when it comes to performance. I conducted a series of tests at various focal lengths and apertures, comparing this to the Canon 28-70L (one of Canon's best) and felt the Tamron performance was outstanding in head to head results! I printed 8x10s on a Canon 9100 of enlarged sections of the images and could see no differences in the results. OK....its possible with optical testing equipment the Canon lens might test better: I'm not equipped with such equipment. But after 50 years of photographic experience, I am certainly capable of comparing prints for resolution and contrast and saturation, and thats what matters! This lens does not disappoint! But just to be sure, I showed the prints to my photo pro buddies who thought the Tamron results were equal to or better than the Canon. I think the construction is very solid and I like the "drag" adjustment feature on the zoom ring. I am diasappointed that there is no manual focus capability while in the auto focus mode. This is a heavy lens, but if you own any of the Canon "L" zooms, this should pose no problems. The filters are only a few more bucks than the 77mm required by several of my Canon lenses...not a big deal. I have not shot in direct sunlight, so I can't comment on flare characteristics, but I haven't shot with a lens YET that didn't have a problem in those conditions. Bottom line, I think this a great performer with a nice range for landscapes and portrait work with a fixed f/2.8 for low light shooting...recommended!

Similar Products Used:

Canon 28-70L Canon 70-200 f/4L Canon 17-35L Canon 28-135 IS (no longer own) Canon 28-105 (no longer own)

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[Sep 16, 2003]
R Lesh
Professional

Strength:

One lens coverage. Sharp and contrasty at all F stops.

Weakness:

Heavy. Would like to have macro capabilities.

Just received this lens and used it the first time this weekend. Very sharp at all F stops. Using on a Nikon D1X and focus is fast and true. Seems as sharp as all my other Nikon lens

Similar Products Used:

Nikon 28-105 macro

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[Sep 08, 2003]
vidsolve
Professional

Strength:

color sat, contrast, range, bright f2.8 max aperture, great image quality at f5.6- f11.

Weakness:

Heavy, not so good at f4, awefull at f2.8

I have shot with this lens for 3 yrs +. I get great results at f5.6 and up. F4 with good lighting can be ok, but i dont like it at f4, f2.8 is a disaster IMHO. 28mm has pronounced distortion at the horizon, ie yoiu see the curvature of the earth, but that doesnt bother me at all. Color saturation and contrast is better than any of my nikkor AIS primes, that is a fact. Image quality is not as good as nikkor primes, but at f5.6- f11, it is very close. contrast and saturation definatley is better than nikkor AIS primes. I use the lens at 105mm all the time with good results, and i like image quality at 28-70 best. It is a very very usefull focal range at constant 2.8 brightness for viewing, the best lower priced zoom for the money for events and weddings.

Customer Service

I have not needed any in the 3 yrs i have owned this lens.

Similar Products Used:

everything under the sun by nikon, tokina.

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[May 27, 2003]
Yakim Peled
Intermediate

Strength:

Very sharp pictures from f/4 onwards. Distortion is minimal (but keep in mind that I don't shoot architecture per se). No zoom creep. Build quality is very good. After reading other reviews, I get the impression that quality control is not particularly impressive. I am probably a lucky guy. It seems that quality control people DID check my sample...

Weakness:

Flare is evident when the sun is inside the frame or just outside it (yes, I constantly use the lens hood). However, it is not that bad. If you are less picky than me, it might not bother you. AF is on the slow side. Filters are expensive. This is nit-picking but nevertheless I don't like it: Length changes when you zoom. Lens hood does not lock and unlock with the assurance of the Canon lenses.

Have it for more than a year and overall, I'm very pleased with it. It's permanently stays on my Canon 7e. Yes, it's big and heavy but OTOH, I'm not a smallest guy in the world myself. It gives very sharp pictures from f/4 onwards and wide open shots are also usable. Want to give an old lady a flattering portrait ? Use this lens wide open on the tele-end. She's going to love you. Just a thought, could it be a wedding photographer's dream lens ? I am going to sell this lens soon as I am moving to Canon's L (70-200/2.8 IS) and primes (35/2 and 24/2.8). F/4 is just too slow and has too wide DoF for me. If it wasn't for this, I would not part from it.

Customer Service

Never needed it. As I said, apparently quality control people DID check my sample...

Similar Products Used:

Canon 28-105/3.5-4.5 USM. It has USM, lighter and smaller. However, it only gets sharp from f/8 onwards. As I like shallow DoF, wide (and sharp) aperture is important for me. For this reason the Canon mostly stays at home.

OVERALL
RATING
4
VALUE
RATING
4
[Mar 04, 2003]
wind yeung
Intermediate

Strength:

price, features, size, sharpness sharpness at 28mm - 85mm colour saturation, colur definition Build Quality for wide range Convenience for trip

Weakness:

Soft at 105mm for F/2.8, accept after F/4, sharp at f/5.6 Resolving Power is acceptable Plastic case Weight

I like this lens for the price, features, size. Also, it is extremely flexible consumer lens with minimal drawbacks from wide range nature 28mm to portraits 85mm. A great starter lens and probably the best lens to have if you can have only one with quality, especially for trip photo hunting. Generally, it is more worth than NIKON MF35 - 105mm F/3.4 - 4.5 with better quailty & price. Don't trust only in the Brand Name of Manufacturer, there are exisiting of many OEM products with low rank quality. Actually, if you only use for Portraits from 85mm - 105mm, this lens is not a good choice for you in F/2.8. Imagine will become only get better after F/4 with iso100 in normal situation. Finally, I can say something you expected that you can get it from this lens.

Customer Service

Never tried

Similar Products Used:

nikon MF 35 - 105mm F/3.4 - 4.5

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
4
[Jun 20, 2002]
David_R_Patterson
Intermediate

Strength:

Well made, clear pictures, good over-all performance at all focal lengths

Weakness:

Filters are expensive, due to size but that is to be expected with a 2.8 lense of this range.

I have used this lense for about 3 years, on a Minolta 500si body. Mostly Weddings, Family Gatherings, Births, and Vacation shots. Extremely well made lense. Durable and Dependable. One must use common sense when handling lense, due to it's size and weight but with proper handling, I have never had any issues with this lense. Sharp, detailed Pictures even under extreme low light conditions, when mounted on a tripod. (I highly recommend using a remote shutter realise) My first Tamron product and I am impressed.

Customer Service

Never had to use, which speaks to the quality of the lense itself.

Similar Products Used:

Older Minolta Prfessional grade, manual focus body/lense combinations and Knoi-Omega Rapid

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
[Jun 03, 2002]
Mark
Professional

Strength:

Sharp, fast aperature, fast focusing, comfortable handling.

Weakness:

None yet

Purchased this lens in spite of some poor reviews on this site. Mainly since many professionals have listed as equipment on their spec sheets in mags and such. I have been nothing but PLEASED with my results. Shot a wedding with it last month and all details were there. It is also fast focusing. Its macro capabilities also are very pleasing. I would highly recommend this lens.

Customer Service

Not needed

Similar Products Used:

Tamron 28-200, Nikkor 70-210,

OVERALL
RATING
5
VALUE
RATING
5
Showing 1-10 of 39  

(C) Copyright 1996-2018. All Rights Reserved.

photographyreview.com and the ConsumerReview Network are business units of Invenda Corporation

Other Web Sites in the ConsumerReview Network:

mtbr.com | roadbikereview.com | carreview.com | photographyreview.com | audioreview.com